Walking towards Brooklyn Bridge Park this past weekend on a
family outing, we came across the sight that represented everything not to like
about Brooklyn. I even took a photo of it because it summed up so much of what
is wrong with our city and world.
There was a long line in front of a brick oven pizza
restaurant. People crowded into a dense rope line like cattle to the slaughter
to pay handsomely for the honor, while a little ways up the street they could
have gotten more food for less and eaten with real Brooklynites at the Park
Plaza Restaurant. And worse than that, they were waiting to pay for brick oven
pizza.
Brick oven pizza is a big scam. It should shame New Yorkers
that some of our most heralded pizza restaurants are overpriced tourists traps
offering crappy food. Somehow the powers that be have convinced millions of
people that there is something authentic about eating poorly-made and
overpriced pizza.
Take a good honest look at a brick oven pizza if you are
ever roped into going to one of these insufferable establishments. You’ll
notice that not only is the pizza weak and thin and the cheese coverage
extremely spotty, but there will usually be bubbled and burned parts of the
crust. You could take off some of these burnt pieces and use them to make a
charcoal sketching if you wanted. Everyone pretends that this is good pizza,
and brick oven pizza restaurants somehow get away with this even though there
are hundreds of good pizza places that can make a
delicious and authentic New York pizza.
If visitors to New York were willing to just travel a little
farther away from the well-tread tourist areas, this con game could be put to
an end faster. Sadly many New Yorkers themselves have fallen into this trap and
gush on about some of these places.
Some of the celebrated brick oven pizza places boast that
they offer a clam pizza, which really means they are failures in both pizza and
seafood. There are too many good restaurants to get pizza and clams, don’t
spend your money on the brick oven hype.
The brick oven pizza deception plays into the innate human
trait to romanticize the past. While craft and tradition are certainly worth celebrating
when they result in something positive, making sub-par pizza just because it’s
old fashioned is stupid. Yes, they had brick oven pizza in the 1800s in New
York. Do you know what else they had? Cholera and Yellow Fever. We shouldn’t be
eating brick oven pizza any more than we should be commuting to work on
horseback or leeching our children when they get colds. Let’s embrace those
technologies that have improved our lives, including ovens that can cook pizza
evenly.
Many people from outside the city are not aware that pizza
making has a long history in New York and they wrongly believe that they must
choose between the artisanal and brick oven swindlers and the legion of
national chains that are sadly permeating New York neighborhoods. This is a
false choice. The five boroughs and many surrounding areas are full of small,
independent pizza parlors that can make you a
delicious pizza.
Brick oven is a “brand” now. Just like you can charge extra
money by calling something “artisanal” or “natural.” I have no doubt that bad pizza makers
are baking their abominable pizzas in regular ovens and then just charging
extra for it. They’re laughing at their self-satisfied marks who think they are
somehow more “authentic” New Yorkers for being dumb enough to get taken by this
racket.
It took years for this sham to get its hooks in the public
and it may take longer to get people to open their eyes to the fact that they
are paying more for less pizza.
So please, say no to the brick oven pizza hustle. There are
still many independent pizza parlors that make real New York pizza.